Comparing Dairy Shoppe Milks: Decanter Strength Versus Lid Style (Surprising Insight) We recently evaluated the Dairy Shoppe Glass Milk Bottle in our lineup, particularly the 4-piece half-pint decanter set with creamery-style lids. The thick glass design immediately caught our attention—a subtle nod to classic dairies, though its weight required some adjustment. While the extra lids offer versatility, we found the interlocking mechanism slightly finicky. Yet, the sturdy construction ensures these bottles withstand daily use, making them a reliable choice for storing fresh milk. The creamery-style lids provide a retro charm, but the decanter shape feels more premium than standard bottles. Our surprising insight? Despite the initial learning curve, the durable glass and lid options make this set a standout, blending nostalgic aesthetics with practical functionality.