Comparing White vs Semi-Gloss Refinishing Kits, Tested... More Than You Think! We recently tackled a stubbornly stained bathroom sink with our 17 oz White Tub and Tile Paint kit, and while the full kit offers impressive tools for a DIY project, we found ourselves debating the shine. The semi-gloss finish, though durable, feels less forgiving than a satin or matte variety—great for glossy bathrooms but prone to showing imperfections in lower light. Because ours was legacy white, the color was forgiving, but for future projects, we’d mix ours with a shimmer or be brave with a true semi-gloss on high-traffic kitchens.Covering 25–30 sq. ft. wasn’t excessive for our(Application of Paint pics), and the low odor(non toxic smell) was the unsung hero of the job. Still, it’s a tough call: semi-gloss for kitchens sinks, white for bathrooms. Our key takeaway? Tools all match, but the paint manufacturer’s shade swatches and UV durability predictions remain the real MVPs.