Surprising Comfort Showdown: Dr. Scholl's vs. Ordinary Insoles... Who Wins? We’ve tested nearly every insole on the market, and Dr. Scholl’s Work All-Day Superior Comfort Insoles truly stood out. Initially skeptical, we noticed an immediate difference as soon as we slipped them into our boots. The contoured support felt tailored to our arches, and by midday, our feet were less sore than usual. Unlike flimsy store brands, ours didn’t bunch up or slip around—just pure, consistent cushioning. The gel padding, layered strategically for shock absorption, made even long shifts feel doable. True to their promise, these insoles delivered superior comfort without compromising durability. We’re swapping out ordinary insoles for these—no contest.